pianist
Glinka. Ruslan and Lyudmila. Overture. Vedernikov | NHK Symphony. 2011
Andrey Korobeinikov
Alexander Scriabin. Piano Concerto op. 20
Part III
Russian narrative—calm, soulful, with a certain glimmering light of hope ahead—is what conductor Alexander Vedernikov immediately brings to my mind. And indeed, he himself was a wonderful storyteller, loving both the open road and Russia. The endlessly unfolding tablecloth of the Russian soul (not the proverbial cliché, but the sheer, authentic essence of it) is present in his first movements of Rachmaninoff’s 2nd and 3rd Symphonies, Tchaikovsky’s 1st and 6th, and in his masterpiece The Legend of the Invisible City of Kitezh. I particularly recall Rachmaninoff’s Third Symphony—with the National Philharmonic Orchestra of Russia (NPR) in Moscow (on that same program was Myaskovsky’s deeply narrative Cello Concerto with the stunning Alexander Knyazev) and in Odense, Denmark: it was with him that I came to love and penetrate into this music; it is a very special work, and I know of no one else to whom it yielded so fully. There, he balanced the constricting chill of symbolism and the Rachmaninovian flow, the demiurgy of meanings and the confession of nostalgia, clarity and obscurity, motion and stillness, a colossal energy as if flying away into memory... At times, when I recall him with the theme from the 2nd movement, I see him photographing some linnet among the Vyatka hills beneath a low-spreading northern sun. In Rachmaninoff’s 2nd Symphony (naturally with the ingeniously heartfelt and fluid lyricism of the 3rd movement), I remember a moment at a rehearsal in St. Gallen connected with a strange (for me, in Rachmaninoff) glissando between two melodic notes (as if balancing between Hungarian flair and some fleeting refinement). As a rule, it either turns out un-Rachmaninovianly “heavy,” or conductors gloss over this strangeness. Not San Sanych: he didn’t “fuss” over it for long; he drew the orchestra’s attention to it and, as he loved and knew how to do, said everything with his hands. What emerged was a “beckoning of the soul,” as if he had inhabited the composer according to the Stanislavsky system and lived through that detail along with its underlying cause.
He loved entirely different facets of Russian music: he passionately loved the active and springy, one might say, witty and inwardly seething Glinka (who conceals this behind a facade of proportion and a love for beauty as an end in itself), as well as the almost steppe-like Sviridov, hypnotizing in his stasis, flowing like a vast river whose breadth you cannot even take in at a glance. His Ruslan and Lyudmila at the Bolshoi was superbly recorded—with what love he would even simply listen to tracks from it and point out the sound of the special trombones whose purchase he had “pushed through” specifically for that production. And with two such people for whom nothing was accidental—both Glinka and Vedernikov—these isolated exclamations of “different” trombones altered the “rhythm” of the entire musical canvas. He badly wanted to hold a full-scale Glinka festival—featuring chamber, symphonic, vocal, and piano music (and, of course, operas)—a festival of a genius whose greatness, like Pushkin’s, only we here in Russia comprehend to the very end.
It was wonderful to play Beethoven’s 5th Concerto, Tchaikovsky’s 2nd, Rachmaninoff’s 2nd, and Shostakovich’s 1st with him: in every tutti, the concerto score seemed to “soar” to the level of a “symphony,” yet he never crushed the solo part itself with this symphonic scale, recognizing that the genre is different in essence. I was particularly delighted with him when we performed Rachmaninoff’s Rhapsody on a Theme of Paganini in London, where I am always searching for the suggestive, the subconscious, chimeras of fear, the inescapable longing for a departed light—whence the well-known jaggedness... and he understood me, and won the orchestra over by his own conviction, and the audience sat as if spellbound (only the critic completely failed to grasp what it was about). I remember how pleased he was afterward (whereas at other times he could simply be polite, as if saying, “well, until next time”). In Beethoven’s 5th, the shapeliness of his energy simply went off the charts: he did not “over-grandize” this canvas, remaining constantly in the process of creating and striking out that inimitable Beethovenian fire, yet doing so with such inner balance that I myself felt just how “twitchy” I was. Interestingly, he conducted the introduction to the 2nd movement very compactly, including in terms of tempo, which in a couple of places made Beethoven’s turns of phrase sound similar to... Grieg’s (so prophetically had Ludwig anticipated him there); I cautiously mentioned this to him, and he very subtly bypassed that sharp corner of perceptual associations we had no need for.
Among symphonic works, I will also never forget Tchaikovsky’s Hamlet at the Concertgebouw, Shostakovich’s 1st in Stockholm, and Glazunov’s 7th with the stunning NHK Symphony Orchestra in Tokyo. Even The Queen of Spades (unforgettable, performed in a single breath choked with suffering) and Aida were interpreted by him as symphonies, and even The Nutcracker (only in The Barber of Seville did I sense how “operatically” he played with that “diamond”)! It was as if he were showing us—accustomed as we were to the grand emotional clichés of other great maestros—the ingenious sides of our beloved composers. Tchaikovsky turned out to be a vibrant interpreter of Shakespeare, and the early Shostakovich a major composer of the 1920s with his own distinct individual style.
Speaking of the NHK: that was an incredible instance where their truly boundless trust in him (the program was outlandish even for Russia: Sviridov, Scriabin, Glazunov) and their extraordinarily conscientious mastery led to Glazunov’s 7th (not even the 8th, the textbook favorite) sounding like something utterly captivating and magnificent. I listened to both concerts with my mouth agape (a few months later he repeated it with the NPR—no, they didn’t quite measure up; we can’t give our all to Glazunov and learn it “like the Japanese”). Sviridov (The Snowstorm) was a revelation altogether, because for obvious reasons the Japanese knew nothing of the dust on the seats of the Column Hall of the House of Unions, the sad eyes of Maya Kristalinskaya, and all that baggage which begins to sound endlessly bleak in the Romance. “Ta-da-da-daaa”—and suddenly before your eyes appear queues, commuter trains, factories, ration coupons, a longing for the Russian 19th century destroyed for no reason by cruel mediocrities (just like in the film Say a Word for the Poor Hussar...). Yet Vedernikov was different—younger, even though he knew and loved Sviridov intimately through his genius father <Alexander Filippovich Vedernikov, singer the>—and they (the Japanese) were like those who had undergone Husserl’s phenomenological reduction of perception. It came out genuinely Russian, not Soviet—beautiful and profound—and it turned out that this music is wonderful not merely for its over-familiarity! Winter Road and the March especially.
I also reflected that the fact San Sanych did not have “his own” orchestra—that is, an orchestra to which he had grown attached the way other great (and not-so-great) conductors do, simply playing by and large with the best in the world—gave him a kinship with the NHK, which has no chief conductor. And I saw with my own eyes and heard with my own ears how eagerly musicians “drank in” his rehearsals at the BBC and NHK, in Switzerland, Denmark, Sweden, Yekaterinburg, St. Petersburg, and Moscow... His respectfulness and friendliness toward fellow musicians, multiplied by service to music of the highest caliber, with a clear idea of what he wanted to achieve and the understanding and skill of how to achieve it, remained in the soul of practically everyone who crossed paths with him. He was a Guide [Conductor] in the poetic sense of the word.
And about his inimitable personality (about what I saw), I will write one more post.
Prometheus. The poem of Fire Op. 60. Andrey Korobeinikov, piano. Alexander Vedernikov, conductor. St Petersburg Philharmonic
Part I
There used to be a broadcast called Neproshedshee vremya (“The Unpassed Time” / “Time Past That Has Not Passed”) on Ekho Moskvy, hosted by Maya Peshkova. The broadcast itself often bore the naive shortcomings of the Soviet intelligentsia—with a pedagogical reverence for universal human values and oppositional winks—yet the tone and atmosphere were remarkably captured, as was the title.
Today, January 11 <2023>, my unpassed time is with Alexander Alexandrovich, San Sanych, Vedernikov on his birthday.
It is remarkable that when speaking of him, it is impossible to establish an order: a stunning “musician and human being” or “human being and musician,” so uniquely and harmoniously were these two hypostases combined in him—one turned toward the cosmos, the other toward people and nature. An incredible musician, a unique human being.
I first felt that he was not simply a great professional conductor at a Scriabin concert with the generally calm and even Helsingborg Symphony Orchestra in Sweden (we played there and at the Stockholm Konserthuset; our recording from there has become my absolute favorite, something clearly “clicked” [https://youtu.be/aj6qD1AB5LU]). It is a somewhat strange piece for a piano concerto, considered by some to be immature (though in reality it represents the pinnacle of a special Scriabin period that I would call “radiant nostalgia”), where only the composer’s very precisely found intonation and a natural attitude toward the “currents of ether” suddenly make one sense an incredible inspiration—at times burning with the smooth candlelight of the soul, at times wholly ablaze with a turning toward the infinite heavens. Already from working on the theme of the 2nd movement with the orchestra, I felt a kind of Russian Bruno Walter—an inexorably broad wing, a sense of proportion, everything simple and right at hand like a pianist, an absolute organic familiarity with the string players executing this theme, and alongside all this—a certain sustained, distant cry of a trumpet, precisely a trumpet of the soul. (The genius and genuine Igor Nikonovich, in his dedication to all things Scriabin, had also spoken to me about the brass-wind nature of most of Scriabin’s themes.) And the outburst-prominences in the first movement, as well as the full-fledged, blazing rapture in the finale, simply struck me... with their inner truth. This was not the outwardly exultant, doused-in-gasoline fire that “built” easy world popularity for two Russian maestros; this was the fire of a Keeper of the Fire.
Right around then, I also noticed his calmly precise approach in working with a soloist: we were discussing the “illumination” of the very first piano note, the character of the dialogue between the first intonation of the piano part and the orchestra. By the way, much of it is written in a very improvisational manner, and I was struck not only by how quickly A.A. would react on stage and “respond” differently (as happens with jazz musicians), but also by how he did it. A slight turn of the hand, a calm yet electrified glance at the necessary instrumentalist or section—and everything changes; and most importantly, not just the framework of the phrase “moves,” but its coloring and poetics as well.
This very combination of blazing fervor, an inner major poet, and a practically Greco-classical sense of proportion and harmony is what made him unique. In conversation with me, among his teachers he once singled out Mark Ermler (whom, alas, I never heard), but to my mind his “roots” lay in the stunning Nikolai Golovanov, whom he both loved and valued, and—perhaps because he was also a pianist—in Bruno Walter, of that same conductorial “aquiline” type.
Part II
Continuing the subject of Scriabin, one cannot fail to mention his Prometheus, especially in St. Petersburg with the Honored Academic Symphony Orchestra—it turned out unforgettably! I think many Petersburgers remember that ringing state of soaring (and “taking off,” as people say now). When the choir entered, singing in doubling, I believe, with the horns, I mentally thanked Scriabin that he didn't write any piano part at that exact moment (since the human element (the piano) in that part of the score made the transition into the universal human (the choir), into the matrix, so to speak)—because after everything that had already been played and how it was played, with that already not-quite-earthy timbre, one’s hair stood on end, goosebumps raced across the skin, and one felt the necessity to levitate. This was not a Svetlanov-style assembled Prometheus, Wagnerian in its genome as an essence concentrated in the coda of a Noh theater performance, and at the same time consecrated by Russian cosmism, by this thirst of ours for light and our intoxication with it.
Moreover, working on it precisely in Petersburg was not easy. Like all great orchestras, the Honored Academic Symphony Orchestra is concentrated on “its own” repertoire, in which they are an absolute reference, and Prometheus cannot quite be said to be part of that. After the first run of the initial rehearsal, as someone devoted to Scriabin’s Prometheus, I walked up to San Sanych and, trying to be delicate but having “grown bold” out of a sense of despair, asked if perhaps we should tell the brass players about the symbolism of the themes they were playing. To this the maestro, instantly touched by my “student” naivety, said: “By no means, goodness gracious!” and began slowly and painstakingly to forge what was needed out of the orchestra as an instrument—and the Honored Academic Symphony Orchestra is a magnificent instrument. He always “played upon the orchestra”! I remember the search for the “nasal” timbre of the horns in the theme of the Creative Spirit, the request to the violin soloist Pavel Popov to play the double-sharp G without temperament, but with the sensation of that super-gravitation of the tone upward (it came out amazingly), the appeal to the choir not to sing academically “ah-ah-ah,” but as if in an “alien language,” and A.A. playfully demonstrated “a-y-u-o” (yet this attitude toward sound as language is precisely what gave it the sacred semiotics of the moment!).
https://youtu.be/zO7QLVBpqtA
From Scriabin—to Wagner, naturally. Once when we were playing in Denmark, the program was entirely un-Wagnerian, and he began showing me (playing) pieces from the Ring, playing them in recordings by various conductors, even though the performance was planned for more than a year later. I was struck by this charge of energy, this “obsession” with a repertoire that matures and matures for years just to burst forth one day! Once he confessed that his departure from the Bolshoi was also personally connected to the fact that for Wagner’s jubilee 13th year the management didn’t approve the Ring. “Well, if not, then why do I need all this?”—he said something to that effect.
A year later, I decided to travel specifically to Odense, where he had gathered the best Wagnerian singers (and the orchestra there, funded in the Scandinavian manner (i.e., consisting by far of more than just Danes), sounded first-rate with him, although with Wagner one could sense them “undertaking an overarching super-task,” but that is how it has to be with such a composition; it cannot be done either “in passing” or “evenly”). I caught The Valkyrie and was struck right from the overture: some kind of volcanic brew of the depths of being, blazing Gothic, transcendental fires of passions taken in their symbolist outline... That rare occasion when I realized I had to go again: according to schedule, I could only make it to Götterdämmerung. What a radiance of D-flat major that was at the end—a true Effulgence! How subtly resolved was the part of Siegfried’s “common-law wife,” who suddenly began to sing “humanly” (Lyuba Petrova), and how it so beautifully contrasted with the “inhuman” Brünnhilde (the American soprano), the singing of Hagen’s cliff (Runi Brattaberg), and somewhere between these two worlds, the brilliant Siegfried (Torsten Kerl).
“Ah, it’s a pity, Andrey, that you didn’t hear Siegfried!”—and in this there was felt such performing happiness when everything “came together,” matured, and worked out! (It’s a pity that because of some singer the recording is unavailable... but perhaps that is how it should be with something great—to sound once “out there,” into eternity.)
He was happy. We were all in seventh heaven in the hall. We ascended.